Posted by Sean Bailey (Phoenixville, United States) on 24 August 2007 in Landscape & Rural and Portfolio.
I put this up on another site and this picture was picked apart for two reasons. They said it was way to common, and because the back waterfall was out of focus. I wanted the other waterfall out of focus to give the image some depth and not to take away from main subject. Let me know what you think. Am I seeing this differently because I took it?
If you like my pictures, please vote for me here. http://vote.photoblogawards.com/photoblog.php?title=Angry_Buddha_Photoblog
VFXY Photos | Cool Photoblogs | Listed on Photoblogs.org
Did you post it on OnExposure perhaps? As a regular contributor to that site, I have had plenty of stuff rejected over the months.
The first thing I notice is the back waterfall is out of focus. Then I notice the reflections in the back pool that are very nice. At first blush, the out of focus background appears to be a technical problem. However, you say that is purposeful, so that is fine. I think the main problem with the image is, despite the background being out of focus, the foreground waterfall is not that interesting. In other words, the stuff in the back ground is more interesting.
24 Aug 2007 9:29am
@Daniel: I see what you're saying. Thanks for the input Daniel.
Sean, I'm a lurker who loves your site but I have no knowledge of photography so I'm not sure whether my opinion will be meaningful or not.
It almost seems as if we are looking at two separate pictures that have been photoshopped. Maybe it's the angle that is somewhat distracting.... I think I might prefer seeing more of the top waterfall & a little less of the bottom whose rock formation overpowers the shot. It's still an interesting pic though.... just not one of your best.
Thanks for sharing your wonderful pics. I do love your work. :)
24 Aug 2007 3:38pm
What a captivating place! Great.
24 Aug 2007 4:02pm
Beautiful...the brown tones are very nice.
24 Aug 2007 4:42pm
I think this photo is great I see nothing wrong with it. I love the reflections and the water coming over the rocks great job.
26 Aug 2007 10:51pm
Actually, when I first looked at this I thought it was so wonderful because you had put the back waterfall out of focus... that in and of itself makes it un-ordinary. Great shot Sean!! The rest are hacks!
27 Aug 2007 12:46pm
Beautiful waterfall. Great tv action too!
20 Sep 2007 10:46pm
PREVIEW ONLY
Add your comment ...
OLYMPUS
Angry Buddha's Photoblog
#gallery 2794074260fcd1e1f307b0986359f3a2
#gallery f1a7c7c27d92de2cc74ac88b631ae519
#gallery 82b9ea789de134f56a401a72a6528608
Angry Buddha's Photoblog